Is This Tottenham’s Strongest XI Once Everyone Is Back Fit? What Is Missing for Roberto De Zerbi?

Tottenham Hotspur have been riddled with long-term injuries for the better part of two years. Whether it was James Maddison and Dejan Kulusevski going without starts for 18 months or Xavi Simons and Wilson Odobert both doing their ACLs, it has been a long time since a Tottenham manager has had a full squad to choose from. But that could change in the next two months…
Lucas Bergvall, Tosin Adarabioyo, Savio, and Mykhailo Mudryk could all be back in action once Tottenham return from the international break. Simons and Odobert are both targeting returns to first-team training by the end of December. Maddison and Destiny Udogie have been building up their fitness over the break after missing back-to-back games. It’s all looking, dare we say it, optimistic for Roberto De Zerbi and co.
| Player | Injury | Return Date |
|---|---|---|
| Wilson Odobert | Knee ACL | December 2026 (training) |
| Xavi Simons | Knee ACL | December 2026 (training) |
| Savio | Muscular | November |
| Lucas Bergvall | Knee | Saturday 21st November |
| Mathys Tell | Ankle | Unknown |
| Mykhailo Mudryk | Ankle | November |
| James Maddison | Lack of fitness | Saturday 21st November |
| Tosin Adarabioyo | Lack of fitness | Saturday 21st November |
| Destiny Udogie | Lack of fitness | Saturday 21st November |
But What Would De Zerbi’s Best XI Look Like if Everyone Was Fit?
Antonin Kinsky: With Guglielmo Vicario on loan at Juventus, Kinsky is the undisputed number one at Tottenham Hotspur. His performances between the sticks have lived up to that title for club and country this season too. There are still some mistakes in there, but it’s important to remember that he is still only 23 – arguably at least five years below what many would consider the ‘peak’ for a keeper.
Pedro Porro: There is a reason Barcelona and Real Madrid are trying to poach Tottenham’s World Cup-winner. Yes, he has shortcomings in defence, but Porro is one of the best ball-playing right-backs on the planet. Much like Trent Alexander-Arnold when he was at Liverpool, you build a team that can cope with Porro’s defending in order to unlock his best attributes going the other way.
Jan Paul van Hecke: That Van Hecke vs Luka Vuskovic debate is going to rumble on all season long, but De Zerbi was determined to bring his ‘son’ to Spurs. After looking shaky in the opening few games, Van Hecke has really settled into Tottenham’s new style in N17. He even leads the Lilywhites for line-breaking passes and remains the club’s top goalscorer this season.
Micky Van de Ven: We all know what Van de Ven can do with his recovery pace – and he definitely needed that side of his game under Ange Postecoglou. Under De Zerbi, however, more emphasis is being put on Micky’s ability to play out from the back and break the lines, and he will become all the better for it.
Destiny Udogie: The simple fact is that Tottenham Hotspur look a better side with Destiny Udogie in it. His pace, his dynamic underlapping runs, and his ability to get to the byline are up there with the likes of Lewis Hall in the Premier League. The problem – he can’t seem to play more than two games without picking up an injury.
Mateus Fernandes: This boy is starting to look well worth the £85m Spurs paid for him, and then some! Tottenham have arguably lacked a player who can pick up the ball from deep and effortlessly break the lines since the days of Mousa Dembele or Luka Modric. Mateus Fernandes looks to be that player.
Sandro Tonali: People were laughing at the £100m price tag a few weeks ago, and it does still look steep, but we are starting to understand what De Zerbi sees in Sandro Tonali. Sometimes, you just need that steady player who does every part of the game to a 7/10, every week. Will he ever become Tottenham’s Declan Rice? I’m not so sure.
James Maddison: See Udogie. James Maddison makes Tottenham tick with his beautiful range of passing and inventive creativity, but he can’t seem to get himself onto the pitch. Repeat injuries, niggles, and a lack of fitness may see Dejan Kulusevski or Xavi Simons take his spot by the start of 2027. For now, he remains Tottenham’s best option.
Mohammed Kudus: He lacks consistency and an eye for goal, but Mohammed Kudus is a joy to watch when he’s in full flow. Spurs fans just want to see it a little more often. You sense that, with his lack of goal output himself, Kudus would perform best with a clinical striker to aim for. Unfortunately…
Dominic Solanke: Spurs don’t really have an obvious clinical striker. Solanke, on his day, is a good target man who brings others into play. But does he get you 20+ goals a season? I think not. He only gets in ahead of Marmoush to offer a more physical presence up top.
Savio: Every team needs that electric player capable of making something happen from nothing. Savio could become Tottenham’s. Much like Kudus, he lacks goals and consistency in his game, but if he can develop, Spurs may have an exciting prospect on their hands.
What Are Tottenham Missing?
If De Zerbi wants to keep building a team that creates chances by isolating wingers one-on-one and feeding passes between the lines, then he needs a new, world-class number nine. If only Harry Kane were still at the club!
Tottenham have been linked with a bunch of options ahead of the January window: Donyell Malen, Georges Mikautadze, Jean-Philippe Mateta, Vangelis Pavlidis, Roberto Fernández, Igor Matanović, Endrick, Folarin Balogun, Gustavo Varela, Eli Junior Kroupi, Nicolò Tresoldi, Dion Beljo, Orri Óskarsson, Younes Ebnoutalib, Igor Thiago.
I would be tempted by Eli Junior Kroupi, although his lack of height and presence does worry me. If De Zerbi prefers someone who has a bit of everything, then Gustavo Varela could be an interesting shout after his nine goals in 10 games for Monza in Serie A so far this season, or Nicolo Tresoldi’s 14 in 17 games for Club Brugge. Victor Osimhen feels like the perfect shout, but it could be too unrealistic for Spurs in January.


No comments added yet. Be the first!